Contents
7 minutes read
26 June 2025
In early 2021, GameStop shares surged over 1,700% in just two weeks. Millions of retail investors rushed in, following online hype and viral posts. However, as the frenzy subsided, many latecomers suffered significant losses. This wasn't a one-off. It's a textbook case of herd mentality in stock market investing, where investors follow the crowd instead of making informed decisions.
For beginners, especially, it's incredibly tempting to chase trending stocks. You see others making quick gains, and you don't want to miss out on the opportunity. But stock market investing advice based solely on what "everyone else is doing" can be dangerous. Emotional decision-making often replaces logic, and that's where problems begin.
What is herd mentality?
Herd mentality bias is baked into human psychology. We're wired to find comfort in numbers. But in the market, that instinct can work against you. Whether it's piling into tech stocks during a bull run or panic-selling during a crash, following the crowd often means reacting rather than thinking ahead.
In this blog, we'll break down what herd mentality looks like in the stock market—and why it's risky. You'll learn how it distorts market performance, exposes you to costly mistakes, and why it's especially tough for stock market investing beginners. More importantly, we'll share practical strategies to help you stay objective, think independently, and build long-term confidence as an investor.
If you've ever felt pressured to jump into a stock just because everyone else is, this one's for you. Let's look beyond the hype and focus on smarter investing.
Understanding herd mentality in stock market investing
Herd mentality in stock market investing occurs when people buy or sell stocks primarily because others are doing the same. It's not about careful research or personal conviction. It's about reacting to social proof and fearing regret or missing out. The herd mentality bias drives this behaviour—our psychological tendency to conform, especially in uncertain situations.
Why does this happen? Human brains are wired to think in groups. In uncertain environments, such as financial markets, people often assume that the crowd possesses knowledge they lack. So instead of asking, "Does this stock make sense for me?" many investors ask, "What's everyone else buying?"
The problem? The crowd is often wrong, especially when emotions run high.
There are many historical examples of herd-driven investing. The dot-com bubble of the late '90s saw investors flood into tech stocks with no profits, purely because others were doing the same. In 2008, real estate and bank stocks fell sharply after years of overconfidence as people rushed to sell, again driven by group panic.
What separates thoughtful investing from herd behaviour is the process. Informed investors consider a company's fundamentals, long-term trends, and their personal goals. Herd-driven decisions rely on momentum and hype. When everyone piles into the same hot stock, valuations get distorted, and the risk of sudden collapse rises.
Take Enron in the early 2000s. For months, analysts and retail investors applauded its "growth," even as red flags piled up. People trusted crowd sentiment instead of checking financial reports. When the truth came out, investors lost billions.
The bottom line: just because a stock is popular doesn't mean it's right for you. Following the herd might feel safe, but it's often a shortcut to poor outcomes.
The impact of herd mentality on market performance
Herd mentality in stock market investing isn't just risky for individuals—it can distort the entire market. When millions follow the same emotional signals, prices drift far from reality. This can create bubbles and fuel crashes, and lead to massive volatility that affects even the most disciplined investors.
Look at the dot-com bubble. In the late 1990s, stocks like Pets.com and Webvan soared on hype alone. These companies had little to no revenue, but their share prices exploded simply because the crowd believed they had to invest in anything tied to the Internet. By 2000, reality hit. The bubble burst, wiping out over $5 trillion in market value within two years.
The 2008 financial crisis followed a similar pattern. Real estate prices rose too quickly as lenders and buyers acted on collective optimism. When warning signs emerged—like rising default rates—investors and institutions rushed to sell mortgage-backed securities. Panic spread, and stock markets worldwide plunged. Herd-driven behaviour helped fuel both the boom and the bust.
These events illustrate the dangers of a herd mentality. In the short term, you might ride the wave and see gains. However, inflated prices often collapse suddenly, hurting those who arrive late. Even long-term investors can suffer if entire sectors crash due to a mass exit.
Market-wide fear and euphoria can also lead to overcorrections. For example, during the COVID-19 crash in March 2020, global markets dropped by over 30% in a matter of weeks. Many companies with strong financials were dragged down just because the crowd was selling everything.
So, what drives these violent swings? Social media and round-the-clock news amplify emotions such as fear and greed, often exacerbating them. A single tweet or headline can now send waves through global markets, usually before facts are verified. If you let the herd guide your decisions, you're reacting, not investing.
Ready to own a piece of the world’s biggest brands?
- Invest in 4,000+ US stocks & ETFs
- Fractional investing
- Zero account opening fees
- Secure and seamless
Start investing in just 2 minutes!
Build your global portfolio.
.png)
Invest in companies you love, like Apple and Tesla.
Track, manage, and grow your investments.
The risks of following the crowd in stock market decisions
Herd mentality in stock market investing can lead you straight into avoidable losses. When you follow the crowd without questioning why, you relinquish control over your outcomes. That's especially dangerous for stock market investing beginners, who may confuse noise for insight.
One major risk? Missed opportunities. If you're chasing the same stocks as everyone else at the same time, you're likely buying high. By the time you've heard the hype, early investors may already be cashing out. Think of GameStop in 2021. Retail investors rushed in after prices started soaring, unaware that much of the gain had already been realised. Many who bought late faced steep losses just weeks after the purchase.
Crowded trades also create false signals. When everyone piles into the same stock or sector, it may have strong momentum. But this can disguise weak fundamentals. If you skip your research, you may end up holding an overvalued asset. Tulip Mania in the 1600s and the cryptocurrency crash of 2022 are reminders that price momentum doesn't always indicate strength.
For beginners, the most significant danger lies in limited experience. It's tempting to copy others when you feel you lack enough stock market investing advice. However, taking cues from online forums, trending apps, or colleagues rarely replaces the need to think critically. And when the market turns, the crowd may disappear, leaving you alone in a declining position.
Following the herd can also build bad habits. You stop learning how to evaluate risk, set goals, or form your strategies. Instead, you hope others are right.
So, what can you do to stay off this path? In the next section, we'll examine strategies that help you make objective, independent decisions, which are beneficial for new investors who want to build confidence and avoid the most common pitfalls.
Strategies to avoid herd mentality in investing
Avoiding herd mentality starts with building your decision-making process—even if you're new to the market. For stock market investing beginners, a few practical steps can go a long way:
1. Do your research. Before buying any stock, dig into the company's fundamentals. Look at earnings reports, profit margins, debt levels, and long-term growth trends. Don't rely on social media buzz or headlines. If you can't explain to yourself why you're investing, you're following the noise.
2. Set personal criteria. Decide ahead of time what makes a stock worth buying. It needs to demonstrate consistent earnings growth over a three-year period. Or it needs to align with your sector knowledge. When you have a checklist, hype is easier to ignore.
3. Think long-term. Ask yourself: "Would I want to hold this stock for the next 3 to 5 years?" If the answer is no, rethink your position. Herd behaviour is often short-term; steady growth comes from patience.
4. Limit how much news you consume. Too much information—especially opinionated content—can confuse more than help. Follow a few trusted sources and focus on data, not speculation.
5. Learn to pause. If you feel excitement or fear while investing, stop and reassess. Emotional decisions often signal herd influence.
Independent thinking requires practice, especially when you're just starting. However, by establishing strong habits early, you'll make better choices and stay focused, regardless of what the crowd is doing next.
Being aware of herd behaviour helps you stay grounded. Whether you're new to investing or not, independent thinking gives you an edge. Keep learning, stay cautious, and always ask yourself: "Am I investing for a reason—or just following the crowd?"
Now that you understand how herd mentality in stock market investing can lead to rash decisions, it's time to build your framework for smarter investing. Start by setting clear goals, identifying what matters most to you, and sticking to a plan that's based on research, not online noise. When the crowd surges in panic or hype, pause and ask yourself if the fundamentals still hold. Your edge isn't speed—it's clarity.
Break free from the herd by focusing on long-term value over short-term trends. This approach helps you avoid the common pitfalls that can harm portfolio returns and confidence. Even if you're one of the stock market investing beginners, staying curious and thinking independently sets you up for stronger, more informed decisions.
Want more practical stock market investing advice like this? Explore trusted resources and tools available through Winvesta to support your investing journey.
Frequently asked questions about herd mentality in stock market investing?
Following the crowd can lead to:
- Buying at the top and selling at a low
- Ignoring warning signs due to collective optimism
- Missing better opportunities you didn't research
For stock market investing beginners, this can mean costly mistakes early on.
You can avoid it by:
- Doing your analysis instead of copying others
- Sticking to long-term goals, even if others panic
- Setting rules for when and why you'll buy or sell
- Limiting exposure to market noise (like trending posts or TV hype)
